FieldNews
Subscribe

Daily oil & gas and construction news for subcontractors

ASA Targets Pay-to-Qualify Fees as Prequal Platforms Draw Fire

The American Subcontractors Association wants standardized forms, transparent scoring and fees disclosed up front on third-party prequalification platforms. Here is what subs can push back on, and how to screen payment risk.

FieldNews Staff|
Editorial image: industry general - ASA Targets Pay-to-Qualify Fees as Prequal Platforms Draw Fire

ASA Targets Pay-to-Qualify Fees as Prequal Platforms Draw Fire

Fees that start low and climb to $3,000 or $4,000 are the sharpest complaint in a new push by the American Subcontractors Association (ASA) against third-party electronic prequalification, ENR reports. The group is not asking to scrap prequalification. It wants the process standardized, scored transparently and priced in a way subs can see before they estimate.

Background

Prequalification, which involves submitting financial data, safety history and work experience, decides whether a sub gets through the gate to submit a price. ENR reports that those gates are often run by third-party platforms.

ASA, in a list of concerns hammered out this summer, is calling for standardized forms, limited project-specific questions, clear scoring logic, data security, and fair and transparent fees. It also asks for standardized annual submissions on core forms, with project-specific questions only when needed.

ASAโ€™s central complaint is a โ€œpay-to-qualifyโ€ dynamic. In the associationโ€™s words, some programs shift platform fees and ongoing verification costs disproportionately to subcontractors, even though owners, general contractors and others in the supply chain also benefit.

Martin Press, CEO of Press Mechanical Contractors in Manassas, Va., and ASA secretary/treasurer, said on a September podcast that third-party platforms lack transparency and can use scoring so rigid that it fails to reflect a subโ€™s full business. Melissa Rossi, CEO of Division 9, a Bothell, Wash., flooring sub, said avoiding the platforms is not an option for many subs. She said fees often start low and scale up, and she wants to know the fee โ€œto the dollar ahead of time.โ€

ENR also reports that some GCs and construction managers say they donโ€™t use services that charge subs, or that they pay the fee themselves. Platform providers say they reduce repetitive submissions, limit renewal fees or promise not to resell sub data.

Analysis

According to ENR, ASA has not asked platforms or GCs to disclose their own financial condition, though the one-way nature of prequalification raises the question. What ASA does say is that prequalification expectations should line up with payment and retainage practices, including timely review of pay applications and change order requests. That is the closest ASA comes to addressing the other side of the ledger.

The logic still holds. Prequalification today is a one-way risk screen: the sub hands over financial statements, safety history and experience, and the GC or owner decides. ASAโ€™s own language about โ€œbalancedโ€ treatment of data, review standards and cost burdens points to the asymmetry. Subs absorb the cost of proving they are a safe bet, while nothing in the process tells them whether the party paying them is one.

Fees are the most negotiable piece. Rossiโ€™s point is that a known fee can be priced into the bid. An unknown or escalating one is a margin leak on work the sub may never win. ASAโ€™s request for fee disclosure before estimating treats the cost as a bid-stage line item. That is more realistic than trying to eliminate the charge, since ENR reports many subs have no way around the platforms.

The form-fatigue complaint is also a cost story. Richard Bright, ASAโ€™s chief executive, described the hours spent on repetitive prequal packets as soft costs on jobs members may never bid. Those hours donโ€™t show up in an estimate, but they come out of the same overhead.

Pressโ€™s account is the one hard data point on leverage. He returned a subcontract unsigned because the other party would not compromise on prequalification, and the fees were waived about 10 minutes later. It is one anecdote, and Press says his long relationships with local GCs that avoid platforms help him. Smaller or newer subs may have less room. It still shows the fee is not always fixed.

What It Means for Subcontractors

  • Ask for the fee in writing before you estimate. Rossi says fees often climb to $3,000 or $4,000. If a platform fee isnโ€™t disclosed until after youโ€™ve priced, you canโ€™t recover it. Request the initial and renewal amounts at invitation to bid, and add them to overhead or the job estimate.
  • Treat the fee as negotiable at subcontract stage. Press got prequal fees waived after refusing to sign. Mechanical, flooring and other trades with strong GC relationships can raise it at the subcontract review step, before signature.
  • Count your prequal hours as a cost. Bright says repeat packets are soft costs on jobs members may never win. Track hours per submission across GCs so you can show which owners and platforms cost you the most, and use that in talks about standardized annual submissions.
  • Ask which GCs pay the platform fee. ENR reports some GCs and construction managers pay it themselves or avoid fee-charging services. Ask during invitation to bid, and favor those GCs when two similar jobs compete for your estimating time.
  • Ask how scoring works. Press says rigid, opaque scoring can fail to reflect a subโ€™s real business. If a platform fails you, ask for the scoring criteria and offer context such as project history and relationships in writing.
  • Build your own payment-risk screen. Pay-to-qualify platforms donโ€™t tell you whether a GC pays on time. ASA has not demanded GC financial disclosure, so ask about pay-application review timelines and change order handling. Those are the practices ASA wants aligned with prequal expectations. Get the answers before you bid, and write them into the subcontract.
  • Check your data terms. Some platforms say they wonโ€™t resell sub data. Ask for that promise in writing before you upload financial statements.

Sources

Get The Field Report

The week in oil & gas and heavy construction: market data, the big story, and where the work is. Every Sunday, in 60 seconds.

Your regions (up to 3)

Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

๐Ÿ“˜

Want the full picture?

Post-Completion Warranty and Punch Work: Protecting Your Margins After the Job Ends

Warranty walks, punch lists, and post-completion callbacks eat into subcontractor margins. Learn how MSA warranty clauses work, when you can push back on mobilization costs, and how to document your way out of disputes.

Read the guide โ†’

More from Virginia

All coverage โ†’
Follow FieldNews
A community project byAimsio