MSHA Proposal Would Keep Silica Limit, Loosen Sampling Rules
MSHA’s updated respirable crystalline silica proposal would keep the lowered permissible exposure limit while rewriting parts of the 2024 final rule, Safety+Health Magazine reports. The agency announced the proposal Nov. 10 and set publication for Nov. 12.
The 2024 rule cut the PEL to 50 micrograms per cubic meter over an 8-hour time-weighted average, half the prior limit. Enforcement has been delayed amid a lawsuit by the National Stone, Sand & Gravel Association in the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. In April, MSHA delayed the compliance deadline “indefinitely” for metal and nonmetal miners.
Proposed changes include:
- Sampling “as frequently as necessary,” with periodic evaluation and post-evaluation sampling requirements removed.
- Citations only for MSHA’s own samples that exceed the PEL in lab analysis.
- Voluntary rather than mandatory medical exams for miners new to metal and nonmetal mining.
- OSHA’s respiratory protection standard (1910.134) incorporated by reference.
- A ban on rotating miners as a corrective action for overexposure.
NSSGA said it is “pleased” and reviewing the text. Rep. Bobby Scott (D-VA) says the proposal weakens protections.
What It Means for Subcontractors
- Hold silica exposure-control purchases, such as monitoring equipment and respirator fit-testing programs, until the final rule and its effective date are known. The comment deadline is Jan. 11, and a virtual hearing is set for 9 a.m. Eastern Dec. 15. FIND: Hold silica exposure-control purchases, such as monitoring equipment and respirator fit-testing programs, until the final rule and its effective date are
- Crews on quarry, aggregate and other metal and nonmetal mine property should plan for 1910.134 respiratory protection requirements. Ask site operators before your next mobilization how they will handle sampling now that it would be “as frequently as necessary.”
- Operators could not use rotation of miners as the fix for overexposure under the proposal. Sub crews working in dusty areas should expect engineering or respiratory controls to be the focus of site requirements.



