Alabama Water Utility Settles $1.4M Arcadis Fee Fight Over Lake Purdy Dam
Central Alabama Waterโs board voted Nov. 13 to settle a $1.4 million engineering-fee dispute with Arcadis over the Lake Purdy Dam rehabilitation near Birmingham, board recordings reviewed by ENR show. Settlement terms have not been disclosed.
What Happened and Why It Matters
The rehabilitation was previously estimated at about $86 million, though ENR notes that is a historical figure, not a confirmed cost to complete. Arcadis, the utilityโs consultant for 22 years, sued in September. It alleged that CAW withheld payment for completed work and tied payment to turnover of project records, according to WBHM. After a state-mandated governance restructuring, CAW picked Jacobs as consulting engineer and approved five-year agreements with seven other firms, including Black & Veatch, Brown and Caldwell, Stantec and WSP.
Work stopped in late December 2025. Arcadis executive Patrick Flannelly had warned the board in July 2025 that excavation into the downstream slope had made the dam โless safeโ than before the project began. CAW said the contractor, Thalle Construction, demobilized Dec. 23. Thalle told BirminghamWatch it had not demobilized and was acting on a Jan. 2 stop-work directive.
Jacobs engineer Mark Kacmarcik told the board in March that the dam structure was โessentially unchanged,โ but partially demolished spillway training walls had reduced its ability to pass floodwater without eroding the riverbanks. The corrective plan calls for rebuilding the walls, protecting exposed areas from erosion, adding a weir wall and installing monitoring instruments. Stantec is engineer of record for the corrective work. CAW cut fiscal 2026 Lake Purdy spending from $22 million to $7.7 million.
By the June 8 board meeting, the left training wall was complete and Thalle was placing roller-compacted concrete on the right wall. About $2.4 million of the $7.7 million had been spent, leaving roughly $5.2 million. Jacobs projected substantial completion around July 31 and closeout in September. CAW did not tell ENR whether the work finished or when permanent rehabilitation resumes.
What It Means for Subcontractors
- Demolition and concrete: Partial demolition of the spillway training walls left the structure less able to handle flood flows. Before demo on any hydraulic or retaining element, get written engineer approval of the sequence and the interim condition. Photograph and log the existing condition first.
- Stop-work protection: CAW and Thalle gave conflicting accounts of whether the contractor left or was ordered to stop on Jan. 2. Negotiate standby, remobilization and demobilization pay for owner-directed stops. Insist that any stop-work order come in writing, with the date and reason.
- Records: Arcadis alleged payment was conditioned on handing over 22 years of project records. Keep your own daily logs, quantities and photos so an owner or engineer change cannot leave your claim undocumented.
- Heavy civil and electrical/instrumentation (E&I): The corrective scope included roller-compacted concrete, backfill, erosion protection, a weir wall (design issued June 3) and monitoring instrumentation. Final grading design was about 70% complete in June. Ask Jacobs program manager Josh Crowe or Thalle whether any packages remain open.
- Pursuit list: Permanent rehabilitation has no confirmed restart date. Watch CAW board agendas for it. Jacobs also presented a 10-year capital plan Oct. 23, so get on the bidder lists of Jacobs, Stantec and the other five-year firms.



