DOL Final Rule Revives Economic Reality Test for 1099 Workers
Construction Dive reports that the U.S. Department of Labor finalized an independent contractor rule Nov. 19 under the Fair Labor Standards Act, centered on an โeconomic realityโ test that weighs worker control and opportunity for profit or loss.
What the Rule Says
The rule keeps much of DOLโs February proposal. Its two core factors are the workerโs degree of control over the work and the workerโs opportunity for profit or loss through initiative, investment or both. Other โless probativeโ factors can also be considered.
DOL named three of those secondary factors: the skill the work requires, how permanent the working relationship is, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production. Wage and Hour Administrator Andrew Rogers said they count only to the extent they show whether a worker is in business for themselves. He added that actual practices of the worker and the company matter more than what a contract allows on paper.
The rule is a return, of sorts, to the first Trump administrationโs 2021 standard, with what Rogers called โmodifications and enhancements.โ The test now covers the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act, which use the same definition of โemployโ as the FLSA. It does not change classification under the Internal Revenue Code or the National Labor Relations Act. DOL also included 14 fact-specific examples, including delivery workers and truck drivers.
Kristen Swearingen of Associated Builders and Contractors called it โa welcome changeโ from the 2024 rule, whose six-factor test she said left employers guessing which factors carried the most weight. ABC and its Southeast Texas chapter sued over the 2024 rule, and that case has been held in abeyance during the new rulemaking. James Plunkett of Ogletree Deakins said courts โwill have the ultimate say,โ but the examples should help small employers.
The rule is effective 60 days after Federal Register publication. Construction Dive did not report the Federal Register publication date. Check federalregister.gov once it posts and count 60 days from that date to set your compliance deadline.
What It Means for Subcontractors
- Pull every 1099 file on active jobs. Start with labor-only crews, owner-operators and individual haulers. For each, document who sets the schedule, methods and tools, since control is one of the two factors that carry the most weight.
- Document profit-or-loss evidence. Note whether the worker owns equipment, buys materials, hires helpers, quotes jobs or bids work on their own. Investment and initiative are the second core factor. Files that show only an hourly rate and a company-issued truck will be hard to defend.
- Compare practice to paper. Rogers said actual practices outweigh contract language. Review whether your subcontract terms match how foremen direct 1099 workers day to day, and fix the mismatches before the effective date.
- Review trucking and delivery arrangements. Drivers and delivery workers are among the occupations in DOLโs 14 examples. Read the examples that match your hauling, water, sand or materials-delivery relationships and test your setup against them.
- Donโt assume the rule settles everything. IRS and NLRA classification are unchanged, so a worker who passes the DOL test can still be questioned under those laws. Have counsel review borderline files.
- Know the long-term crew risk. Skill, permanence and integrated production are secondary factors. A long-running labor-only sub is not automatically an employee, provided the control and profit-or-loss evidence holds up.




