Better Incident Debrief Questions Than "What Were You Thinking?"
A crew that works a shortcut successfully 50 times starts calling it experience, and that is the hazard. In a column for ISHN, safety consultant Michael Coon uses a roadside photo of three workers, a backhoe bucket and a ladder-height task to argue that investigators should ask why an unsafe method made sense to the people doing it. Coon, a CSP and principal advisor at Kyanite Safety Advisory, says none of the three believed anyone could get hurt, and that nobody gets a message saying โthat worked, but you got lucky.โ
He points to equipment limits, production pressure and changing site conditions as common drivers. Sometimes the cause is habit, convenience or overconfidence, or the company did not give the crew what it needed.
What It Means for Subcontractors
- Use these debrief questions: Coonโs list includes โWas the right equipment available?โ, โWas there pressure to finish?โ and โHad this worked before?โ Add โWhat would make the safer way easier?โ Ask them right after an incident or near miss, before anyone assigns blame.
- Find the improvisation before it injures someone: Coon suggests walking jobs to spot homemade tools, skipped steps and equipment doing work it was not built for. Ask crews what part of the plan never survives contact with the job, and fix the gap this quarter.
- Document conditions, not just violations: Our read, not the sourceโs: written findings that capture schedule pressure, missing tools and prior successful use should give OSHA and WCB investigators a clearer record than โworker failed to follow procedure.โ Coon himself would still stop the work in his example.




